
Image credit: Tom Visser
Music and Text by Sinead O’Connor
Direction and Choreography by Sonya Tayeh
The Hall, AVIVA STUDIOS
★★★★☆
Whatever it may bring, I will live by my own policies, I will sleep with a clear conscience, I will sleep in peace. If I hope for anything as an artist, it’s that I inspire certain people to be who they really are. My audiences seem to be people who have been given a hard time for being who they are.
Sinéad O’Connor, Rememberings 2021
Few artists have worn their wounds as defiantly as Sinéad O’Connor with a voice that could cradle grief one moment before erupting into righteous fury the next. THE SURGE, premiering in Manchester before moving to New York, creates a compelling tidal pull between the vulnerability and rebellion that defines the essence of both the artist and the woman.
This is dance theatre fuelled less by narrative than by sensation. The movement surges in relentless waves, bodies gathering and scattering as though caught between communion and isolation. At times such as during Tiny Grief Song, bodies ripple and flow like drifting notes scattering across a sheet of music. Sonya Toyeh’s choreography oscillates between explosive physical release and moments of almost unbearable stillness, allowing silence to speak as eloquently as movement. At its best, the company captures the contradictions that made O’Connor such an unforgettable presence: tenderness wrapped in steel, fragility refusing to surrender with a celtic unwillingness to go gently into that good night.
O’Connor’s own narration from her 2021 memoir Rememberings and her glorious music sit at the heart of the evening and are thoughtfully woven into the choreography. Sound and movement converse, each amplifying the emotional resonance of the other. There are passages where the dancers appear almost possessed by rhythm, rather than simply responding to it, creating images that linger long after the lights fade. The lighting design by Tom Visser perfectly complements the choreography and lights the dancers as though they are caught in multiple tableaux from an Annie Leibovitz shoot.
Visually, the production possesses an austere beauty. The stage feels both expansive and intimate, with lighting carving shifting emotional landscapes from shadow and glare. Costumes by Márion Talán de la Rosa avoid easy iconography, hinting at O’Connor’s unmistakable silhouette without reducing her to imitation. The result is an aesthetic that honours her spirit rather than attempting to recreate it.

Image credit: Tom Visser.
The ten mature dancers bring their skill and passion, blended with years of technical and life experience to this labour of love and it shows in every nuanced and physically demanding movement. As a ninety minute dance piece, not every sequence lands with equal force. Some extended ensemble passages begin to circle familiar emotional territory, slightly diluting the production’s otherwise fierce momentum. Yet even these quieter moments feel purposeful, reflecting the repetitive cycles of pain, resilience and renewal that shaped O’Connor’s life. In Just Like U Said It Would B they are like whirling dervishs set free in a chapel at midnight. Lisa Race is compelling in I Do Not Want What I Haven’t Got while Karine Plantadit seems to fragment during the haunting Tiny Grief Song. Bold, vibrant moments like Red Football and Mandinka have much of the audience yearning to join in.
What ultimately makes THE SURGE so affecting is its refusal to canonise its subject. There is no sanitised martyrdom here. Instead, the work embraces complexity, inviting us to remember a woman who challenged institutions, expectations and audiences alike, often at enormous personal cost. It asks us not simply to mourn Sinéad O’Connor but to consider why voices like hers remain so necessary.
By the closing moments, the stage seems charged with something approaching collective remembrance. The applause that follows feels less like appreciation for technical accomplishment than gratitude for an act of artistic courage. THE SURGE does not attempt to explain Sinéad O’Connor. It honours her by embodying the uncompromising emotional truth she carried throughout her life. Like the woman herself, it refuses to soften its edges, and is all the more powerful for it.














